PARIS MANIFESTO (September 22, 2008)
Once a mere cultural resource (2000-2004), this site was, little by little, led to offer a tribune to those brave scientists who dare expose the growing pseudo-science (“1 hookah=200 cigarettes” “sweep-it-under-the-carpet” so-called ““waterpipe””™ “science”) and whose now open objective is PROHIBITION. We consider prohibition of smoking as antithetic to the spirit of world major religions (Taoism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Communism, Judaism, Christianity, etc.), particularly the 2nd and 5th ones. Against this new pseudo-scientific obscurantism, we invite you to RESIST in the field: on campuses, hookah lounges, etc. WE HAVE WON THE BATTLE in France where hookah lounges stayed open thanks to our friend’s debunking of the great fraud about “passive smoking” (which was already a fraud in relation with cigarette smoking...). We are also firmly committed to fight those who shamelessly promote, in the absence of any evidence and sound study, the pharmacological treatment of supposedly “hookah addicts” (read here).
World and Ever Historic Premiere: Study (May 2008, Online Free) on HOOKAH (Shisha) and CANCER Markers: You’re Dead!
CHINESE SPANISH FRENCH ARABIC RUSSIAN ENGLISH
EXPLOSIVE WORD PREMIERE: Joint Egypt-Saudi-French Nuclear Study Establishes Hazards of Iran Mass Entertainment Weapon (Hookah Smoking).
Letter of Apology to All Cigarette Smokers...
The 7 Fatal Errors in WHO ""Waterpipe"" Report
The Mid-Decade Edition (2002): The World of Hookahs...
1997 - 2007 : The Narghile Decade
>> 1997 (LEFT) : "Le narguilé". An Anthropology of Narghile (Hookah, Shisha), 262 pages. Black and white. The book that shook the world 10 years ago, by letting hookah smoking go global and become a world epidemic ? Isn't anthropology a dangerous game ?
>> 2007 (CENTRE):
"Tout Savoir sur le narguilé. Société, Culture, Histoire et Santé". Everything You Always Wanted to Know about Hookahs. Society, Culture, Origins and Health Aspects.
256 pages of up-to-date scientific facts (incl. censored ones) made available to the widest audience. Colour. CLICK HERE to display FULL PRESENTATION
Note: includes the critical analysis (in English) of the WHO (World Health Organization) report on "waterpipe tobacco smoking", the first ever published by this United Nations agency.
Order: Maisonneuve et Larose (15, rue Victor Cousin. 75005 Paris). +33 1 4441 4930/36 ; facsimile: +33 1 4325 7741. servedit1 [a] wanadoo.fr
Online through:
Bibliomonde, Amazon, Alapage, Fnac, etc.
>> 2007 (RIGHT): Bertrand DAUTZENBERG and Jean-Yves NAU's book ("Tout ce que vous ne savez pas sur la chicha", Paris, Ed. Margaux-Orange), respectively Chairman of OFT (Office Français du Tabagisme) and columnist in Le Monde daily newspaper, have actually pirated (or plagiarized, according to definitions) Kamal's own writings and publications (including materials censored by the two scientific pirates, themselves !).
“Plagiarism is globally recognised as a serious academic offence” (The Lancet)
NOTE: The book was actually prepared by a crowd of experts. Just to mention a few of them, it is said that the OFT’s team members [free transl.]: particularly Joseph OSMAN, Pascale SOMMERA, Maria OELCHANIDIS and Lalla TRAOREL , have been major actors in the «chicha» (shisha, narghile, hookah) project… (pages VII et VIII). Therefore, it is a collective piracy.
>FULL STORY HERE about this great scientific fraud where you will also learn how these "experts" take a Shish-Kebab for a Shisha (page 30-31)... and warn you that "The great risk is that shisha, progressively, take the place of cigarettes" (page 58 of their book. A sentence put in bold characters by the authors themselves)... A "great risk" for whom ?
>> Related story (Oct. 2008):
Plagiarism and Flavors. Bertrand DAUTZENBERG, President OFT, Comes Back with a New Definition for Shisha: a ““War to Tobacco” Tobacco Product" !
>> Related story :
A New Apprentice-Plagiarist on Stage: Tobaccologist Patrick LOUICHE
__________________________________
10 Years Back (
1997)...
Although it is a familiar object for a billion people in the world, the four hundred year old hookah (narghile, shisha, "water pipe", "waterpipe"™, "hubble-bubble") seems struck by a strange silence [This article was written in 1997]. Most encyclopaedias overlook it completely, while the mass media seems to be more concerned with problems considered as "serious" and dynamic than by folkloric and inert objects. It is however undeniable that this tool is used daily, for hours on end, by over a hundred million men and women, in Asia, Europe and Africa, at the local coffee shop or at home. By opening its columns to a presentation of this object and this practice that lies at the very heart of Mediterranean conviviality, Rive magazine deserves our gratitude for going back to the true meaning of discovery.
FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions): HERE
OUR POLICY OF SCIENTIFIC CRITICISM
Individuals cited in these columns are generally authors of public documents or statements (e.g.: in scientific journals or national newspapers) for which they are fully ACCOUNTABLE. Some of them are even notorious defamers and plagiarists/counterfeiters.
From the beginning, we have decided that we wanted visitors to know who are the actors involved in the “asymmetric war” (
Public Health David against Anti-Tobacco Goliath ; One against a Thousand) raging behind the open hookah scene. We gave the full names of people who participated, in one way or another, in a defamation campaign at the highest level; of plagiarists/counterfeiters of the scientific work actually defended on this site (because of the ugly censorship); but also of the authors of tremendously partisan and erroneous pseudo-scientific publications that have been fuelling a huge confusion over the past years with the now well known negative impact on Public Health.
When an end is officially put to such a scorched earth policy (driven by censorship, killing equations like “1 Hookah = 200 cigarettes” and the like, etc.)(1), and collaboration, at last, put on the agenda, then names will be removed, not before. Even if the recent blitzkrieg of “new studies” bodes no good news, we remain open and optimistic. Peace on Earth would be possible again (Dec. 7, 2007).
(1) “If they want a One Hundred Years’ War, I will be standing behind the scientific barricades and they may be assured that I will not know Jeanne d’Arc’s fate” (quoted from press release Dec 1, 2007).
[In other words: take care of what you state in public if you wanna not see your name here and mind what you write and publish if you wanna not scientifically perish. This really is the limit now !]
>> Nuestra Amiga DIANA (Colombia) Talks about Her Impressions and Experience
"NATIONAL" BANS on Shisha Smoking: Heading Happily Towards a Tobacco-Free, Molasses-Free and Fruits-Free World...
The Invention of Hookah (Shisha, Narghile) «Passive Smoking» through Repeated Scientific Misconduct and Fraud
(A Necessary Step for the Tobacco-Free Earth Geo-Political Agenda). Communiqué (March 26, 2008)
“Hookah (shisha, narghile) “Passive Smoking” is a Fraud [Le «tabagisme passif» du narguilé est un leurre]. Communiqué (Paris, 16 février 2008)(Fake Image by French official governmental source: INPES = Institut National pour la Prévention et l'Education à la Santé)
"Seven Thousand Billions of Ultra Fine Smoke Particles
in a Single Hookah (Narghile, Shisha) Session and Yet its Users are Still Alive…"
(Dec. 1, 2007)
>> The UK (United Kingdom) BAN
Let my son and me teach you how to smoke
“One Hookah Would Equal 200 Cigarettes and European “Colonialism” (sic !) (*) Would Now Be the Cause of the Hookah (Shisha, Narghile) Catastrophe ?”
The author wonders whether “these “experts”, apparently called in emergency by ASH (Action on Smoking and Health) to help it enforce a ban on “Shisha Lounges” in the United Kingdom”, do not actually “Defend, Instead, a New form of "Imperialism"
(If we May Use a Phraseology Similar to that of These Experts...)
Aiming at Endorsing the Bush Neo-Conservative ““Great” Middle East” “Vision” in the field of Public Health”…
He concludes that “these “experts” are actually 200 times more dangerous than hookahs because they are dangerous for science and, beyond, for public health.” (Apr. 25, 2007)
(*) and why not Eau-de-Cologne...alism to make it smarter ?
>> The French BAN:
Two Prominent Public Health Scholars Warn on Alcohol & Tobacco Policies: Moral Hygienism, State Puritanism or Industrial Lobbies ? (Nov 19, 2007) (in French)
Narguilé (Chicha) et Pollution Assistée par Ordinateur [Hookah and Computer-Aided Pollution] (Nov 2, 2007)
Critique of Open Letter to President of French Republic: « Lettre ouverte au Président de la République » par la Ligue Nationale contre le Cancer
>> [Hookah (shisha, narghile), Anthropology and The Law]. Communiqué (8 janvier 2008): Le Narguilé, l’Anthropologie et la Loi (English version button available)
May 1968-2008 in Paris: Police is Here to Stay (Paris, 40 ans après Mai 68: la police (de la pensée, pseudo-scientifique, ...) est toujours là...)
In Rare Historic Video Interview, Prominent Public Health Scholar in France Smokes Out Truth and Nothing But Truth about Tobacco & “Second-hand Smoke" (Jan 29, 2008). In English: HERE
French original:
“Toute la vérité, rien que la vérité” sur le tabac et le «tabagisme passif». Le courage multidisciplinaire et indiscipliné d’un savant hors du commun
PASSIVE SMOKING. Top Tobacco Authoritative Expert Debunks European Report (“Lifting the SmokeScreen"). Asks: “Epidemiological Study or Manipulation ?"
Important Health Warning!
For centuries now, dozerns of millions of people have been using the narghile (hookah, shisha, "water pipe", "waterpipe"™, "hubble-bubble") in a "recreational" way, that is once or twice a week, once a month or on occasions. However, by no means, this method can be an alternative to cigarette smoking. If you are a dependent cigarette user thinking of quitting this way, then you may be wrong. Stop deluding yourself right now ! The only thing you may succeed in is to become a hookah chain smoker. Are you ready for this ? So, we invite you to take psycho-medical advice or, better, efficient non-medical advice with nice people like
Un air neuf ("A New Air". "A Desire Cannot Be Addressed with a Ban"). For more information, please refer to the relevant section of this site or get in touch with us through the “Contact Us” page.
Thinking of Quitting Hookah Smoking ? Not Now! Voice your Indignation First
After 2 erroneous reports released by WHO (World Health Organization) (1st erroneous report ; 2nd erroneous report], an erroneous and extremely bad report from the American Lung Association and now a French book representing a major scientific fraud in the history of tobacco research (apart from being an act of intellectual piracy), time is now for mass mobilisations against obscurantism, fundamentalism, fanaticism, violence, intolerance and censorship.
Unite and march ! See the case of Samir who says he is «Un fumeur de narguilé qui ne veut pas arrêter de fumer» (a hookah smoker who doesn’t want to quit...)
Read Critiques of the 2 Erroneous World Health Organization Reports on "Waterpipe™ Tobacco Smoking"
>> (LEFT) A Critique of the [2005] WHO's TobReg "Advisory Note" entitled: "waterpipe™ Tobacco Smoking: Health Effects, Research Needs and Recommended Actions by Regulators. Journal of Negative Results in Biomedicine 2006 (17 Nov); 5:17.
http://www.jnrbm.com/content/5/1/17 ()
The 7 Fatal Errors in WHO ""Waterpipe"" Report
We wish to thank those brave and independent scientists who are beginning to break the world embargo and censorship on different views. The above critique has been cited, as a fully scientific reference and side by side with the WHO report, by:
++ The JEWISH TELEGRAPH (August, 9, 2007)
++Pam REES, Directorate of Public Health, 2007 and the Leicester City NHS (National Health Service), Primary Care Trust: Facts about Sheesha
++Study by Team of Lung Specialists
Has WHO Falsified Translation into Arabic in order to Avoid Outrage over Statement on Hookah Use by Children and Parents in the Arab World ?
>> (MIDDLE)
The WHO Seriously Erroneous 1st Expert Report on "Waterpipe"™ : Wrong and Dangerous in Any Form or Disguise, LAUNDERED or RECYCLED Form ! Read COMMUNIQUE (Cochrane Reviews Scientific Credibility Stained by "Waterpipe"™ Group)
>>(RIGHT) WHO [2007] EMRO Erroneous Peer-Reviewed US-Egyptian Expert Report
WHO-EMRO (World Health Organisation - Eastern Mediterranean Regional Office) and ESPRI (Egyptian Smoking Prevention Research Institute). Shisha Hazards Profile “Tobacco Use in Shisha - Studies on Waterpipe Smoking in Egypt”. Cairo, 14 March 2007. ISBN: 978-92-9021-569-1. 84 pages.
>>(FAR RIGHT) Serious Errors in World Health Organization New Report on “Scientific Basis of Tobacco Product Regulation” (communiqué Dec. 24, 2007). Note: Full critique upcoming.
_________
ABOUT THE FIRST REPORT (LEFT):
>>> Letter (Sept, 7, 2007) to Dr Margaret CHAN, Director-general of WHO (World Health Organization) requesting the dissolution (winding up) of WHO TobReg
and "If necessary -in view of the expected reluctance to commitment by influent involved parties-, the setting up of an International Tribunal (The Hague) to establish charges against those researchers and their affiliated organisations who have imposed, day after day over the past years, a mafia-like system".
>>> Last Comments (Aug-Sept 2007) by WHO TobReg Officials (Erik DYBING, Jack HENNINGFIELD) and the authors of the WHO Erroneous report (Thomas EISSENBERG, Alan SHIHADEH, Wasim MAZIAK and Kenneth WARD)
>>>
Time seems now ripe for a quick “bio” of these important people (based on the recent Letter to Dr Margaret Chan)
The Waterpipe™Gate Files
Follow "The Waterpipe™Gate Files" politico-scientific thriller: only on... The Sacred Narghile. Stay with Us !
READ Related analysis about the geopolitical meaning of the neo-word ““Waterpipe””™, a dangerous nominalism for the world public health, recently advertised again by new "expert" Dr Sebastian THOMAS from Libya:
>> Libya Now Victim of ““Waterpipe””™ Contamination. Another Twist of the “Bulgarian Nurses” Series ? (Aug. 08, 2007)
READ Raven K-S' Reaction:
Raven’s Yellow Curtains. A Letter from Raven K.-S. (raven[at]corax.com), sent March 20, 2007. This Citizen Obviously Wants to Share His Own though Peculiar Experience of Hookah Smoking
Find what’s "wrong" with this picture !
Official “Experts” who were appointed by WHO (the World Health Organization) to prepare reports on hookah (narghile, shisha, “waterpipe”™) smoking could not distinguish between a burning and a heating process (1st Erroneous Report), between smoking products (2nd Erroneous Report) and even between hookah and cigarette smoke (American Lung Association Erroneous Report)... And, recently in France, ""top" "experts"" take a Shish-Kebab for a Shisha ... What's next ? Japanese Sushis ?
Communiqué (October 29, 2007):
The Cochrane 2007 Review Masquerade on ““Waterpipe”” Smoking Cessation
(by Wasim MAZIAK, Kenneth WARD and Thomas EISSENBERG), its By-Products and the Suspect Unbalanced Focus on ““Waterpipe”” Smoking vs. Cigarette Smoking
For Miguel, "we need an honest test with all variables explored"
COMMUNIQUE: La rage et l’orgueil contre... le narguilé (in French) (automatic) ENGLISH: press HERE
A critique of “Narguilé : attention, danger!» (accessed June 29, 2007), a story (*) written by Pascal DIETHELM,
a member of the Governing Board of the French CNCT (Comité National Contre le Tabagisme). The Sacred Narghile awarded him the Golden Stupidity Palm for his dangerous following statement:
« Pire encore, de nombreux parents, en toute innocence, permettent à leurs enfants, parfois de très jeunes adolescents de 12 ans ou moins, de se réunir en groupe avec des amis dans le logement familial pour fumer le narguilé, alors qu'ils n'accepteraient pas que ceux-ci fument des cigarettes. »
(*) based on (or conversely) a campaign (propaganda or prevention ?) elaborated by: OxyRomandie ; CIPRET-Genève ; UICC ; Département de l'économie et de la santé de Genève and Organisation mondiale de la santé (World Health Organization)
COMMUNIQUE (Dec 15, 2007): Study on US “Waterpipe”™ Users by US-Syrian Center: from Serious Errors to ““Waterpipe”” Fixation, Fallacies, Fallacism and Religious Obsession, etc.
1967-2007: Aqui se Queda la Clara. A Tribute to Ernst WYNDER and Ernesto Che GUEVARA
Other Strange News
About This Site
The Sacred Narghile Team: Alex, Juan, Genevieve, Diana and kamal (ex-officio). From the beginning, we have been committed to fight junk science and obscurantism in relation to hookah studies. We have been saying, again and again, that we want sound and independent scientific research where there would be no room for bias, politics, censorship, plagiarism, crusades and witch-hunts. Noteworthy is that the war declared on the "Peace Pipe" was waged in the wake of 11 September 2001 (Read: “An Enemy at Last” by Ignacio Ramonet)
Anyway, controversy and debate are essential for the progress of science. This site was launched 7 years ago as a direct reaction against blatant censorship on the early scientific comprehensive work carried on by K.C. one decade ago. The protagonists were researchers of the American [US] University of Beirut (particularly Monique CHAAYA) who thought it was not necessary (and perhaps dangerous…) to cite this early literature. The same scenario took place again a few years later with the total blackout imposed by the staff of the US-Syrian Center for Tobacco Studies
From then, this site has become a free tribune for all censored materials in the field of hookah studies: not the least is the critique of the WHO (World Health Organization) report on "waterpipe™ tobacco smoking", the first ever published by this United Nations agency. It took its author a full year before finding a truly independent and truly peer-reviewed journal that would accept to publish it.
*************************
We don’t receive MONEY neither from the Pharmaceutical Industry (wealthy dealers of nicotine in the form of patches and chewing gum) nor from the Tobacco Industry nor from the US and international funding agencies (NIH, RITC, etc.).
We have been working with our brains only. So, time has come now for a severe overall evaluation of the quality of the numerous publications to be found in the market.
We are happy to see now how a new generation of researchers can write studies without citing any of Thomas EISSENBERG, Alan SHIHADEH, Kenneth WARD, Wasim MAZIAK and their blind followers. Censorship is like a boomerang.
*************************
This site is NOT the site of the independent researcher we consult for international and scientific matters. Go to his personal pages if you want to: Personal Page
This site is a collective property. Or, let's put it this way: we are his FAN CLUB. We like him for his open mind and the quality of his work but, first of all, because he has been censored for a long time at the highest level on both academic and professional levels. His writings an critiques (on health aspects for instance) are and will remain unavoidable for any independent researcher. Our bibliography only mentioned his references for a long time simply because, when we started off five years ago, the sole substantial and comprehensive (health aspects as well as social, cultural, historical ones, etc.) work carried on in this field was his. And still it is today to a great extent. Evidence can be found here with the
List of his publications
As of March 2007, the only sound not-confusing scientific literature (from acceptable to excellent), authored by other researchers than he, can be summarised in the following short list:
OTHER THAN KC' STUDIES
These researchers deserve our greatest respect. Besides, all of his longstanding efforts have been oriented towards a sound objective scientific transdiciplinary approach of the hookah (narghile) issue, far from fear-arousing and ideology. We share this approach.
From the outset (1995), he has always invited people to join him in this exciting research: for publishing joint papers for instance, setting up an international research centre, an international association, and so on. This invitation is still open to people who still know the meaning of the word “sharing” if they ever experienced it.
Unfortunately, we have seen how some people have taken advantage of the stuff and clues offered for free on this site and even forayed it. Sadly enough, we have seen how, in recent papers, neither the name of our friend nor that of this site were quoted in these “original” articles. A recent exception is a medical study carried on by Knishkowy and Amitai (which however credit our site with wrong statements about “drugs”…). "Anthropology" is "apology" or "folklore" only for those who cannot see the obvious link between health and the socio-cultural setting.
Genevieve, Assistant Researcher, Summer 2006.
SHISHATTITUDE 2007: (Medical) Anthropology as an Art of Self-Defense against Obscurantism…
###################
CRIMININALIZING DISSENT IN RESEARCH
Wasim MAZIAK’s call for action openly refers (n°40) to The Sacred Narghile site: “On the other side of the equation, media outlets are emerging with disguised ownership that promote the waterpipe by minimizing the evidence about its negative public health potential [40]”
Although his declaration of own scientific bankruptcy made us sick, we decided to reply although partially:
““Waterpipe””™: Time for Action on Scientific Integrity and Accountability, Sacking, and Paying Back Funding of Useless Biased ““Waterpipe””™ Research
########################
OBSERVATORY on HOOKAH and HEALTH (Narghile and Health)(Shisha and Health). Scientific Studies about the Hazards and Dangers of a New Smoking Habit
>>>> THE ONLY SITE on Earth for the critique of pseudo-science on hookah. And God said: “Go and Multiply Yourselves...”
"Don’t Be Afraid” (Jesus Christ)!
“Don’t Be Afraid” of intellectual and pseudo-scientific terror! Light will overcome the darkness warfare ! (be it from WHO, whoever or whichever supra or superpower). Dare Doubt, Criticize, and Publish your own Analysis !
_________________________________
Warning to Fanatics (""Anti"-tobacco" pretenders, scientific and/or religious...)(*): What hell do we mean by 'Sacred Narghile', title of this site?
(*) that is, those who want to make Public Health History. Read this: “Anti-Tobacco” Organisations Exposed: Official Scientific Trustworthy Source States that Their Objective is “making global public health history” (Banning smoking in private homes, etc.)
Muslims reject the worship and idolising of images and they could be right, particularly in this world polluted by commercial advertising... (What do the French Anti-Advertising militants (English: HERE) think ?)). Indeed, Islam's highly refined civilisation
(see this or that for a quick overview) has greatly contributed to the development of narghile (hookah, shisha, "water pipe", "waterpipe"™, hubble-bubble) for centuries. Therefore, it must be clear that we use the attributive adjective “sacred” in the figurative NON-RELIGIOUS sense conveying simultaneously the meanings of importance (for the underlying culture) and "mystery". Actually, this is how the vast majority of non-Muslims have always perceived narghile.
>> LAUGH ! “Other websites promote hookah use as chic and elegant (hookahculture.com) or as part of a unique lifestyle (insidehookah.com) and hookahs as objects of religious veneration (sacrednarghile.com)”. Source: BACCHUS (White Paper on Hookah Use). Since Bacchus is the Greek god of wine, is this an "Undeclared Competing Interest" ?